I HATE big fake smiles in photos of children. I HATE "say cheese". I hate that moment when children go from just "being" in front of the camera to "posing" and the self conciousness and self awareness that comes with that. I hate that many children come to a point of not wanting their picture taken because they hate being asked to stand still and smile. I could rant on, oh yes I could... but let's let pictures tell the story.
The other day the light was decent for February and Adeline was happy and for once I'd done something with her hair, so I thought I'd try taking some pictures of my beautiful girl.
Adeline wasn't into it, and here she is giving her "I'm barely tolerating you, Mother" smile and hoping that I will be satisfied and leave her alone. Yes, she's learned to fake smile because that's what the world expects of children - that they will learn to stop what they're doing, look at the camera and approximate a happy face.

Now I admit - this isn't a bad picture. Most people would be very satisfied to have a picture of their child making eye contact and looking pleasant. Many people would have put their camera away after this picture, but since Adeline wasn't saying "no" to pictures (which she is always free to do) I decided to keep at it. I told her that she doesn't have to smile, she doesn't have to sit still and that I'm just going to hang out with her...and keep taking pictures. If I had stopped after Adeline "said cheese" I would have missed this shot, which was the one taken immediately after the smily one. It shows how she's really feeling...

And who says a solemn picture isn't a "good" picture? Certainly no child goes around grinning every minute of the day and I want to remember all Adeline's faces - sad, mad, bad, serious, silly, solemn, laughing, crying...all of them.
After a minute she starts to forget the camera is there and just gets goofy.

I ask Adeline to please keep her stinky feet out of the picture, and I get this picture - how Adeline looks when she is laughing as hard as she can laugh. Now there's a face I want to remember!

Then it's time to move! If I'd put my camera away then because the posing was done I would have missed Adeline's pony-tails swinging as she ran in from the kitchen...

Or her looking as graceful as a ballerina as she practiced her spins.

And then there was the moment when Adeline put her head down and said "Time to come sit on the sofa with me Mama".

And the best part was, because picture taking was fun for her and just a time to hang out with Mama, after her nap she asked to do "More stinky feet pictures, please!" and in just a few minutes I took these pictures of my lovely girl...





Now that's how Adeline looks when she's smiling! She's relaxed and smiling with her whole body - such a difference from her stiff fake smile.

I know Adeline is going to continue to "smile for the camera" and even "say cheese" because when anyone but us takes her picture that's what's expected and that our philosphy means that sometimes we miss getting a photo of that special occasion or special outfit because Adeline would rather do something else than take pictures, but for us it's worth it. So far Adeline is able to continue to be herself in front of the camera and we hope it will always be that way. Only twice has she ever come right out and asked me to stop taking photos and of course I did it right away as I never want that to become a power struggle and to have her decide she doesn't want her picture taken at all anymore. I know she's still very little, but if we can continue to have picture making be a fun activity or have her just be able to ignore the camera and just do what she's doing while I take photos, then we'll be very happy! Adeline is very interested in photography and is eager to be behind the camera - if only I could be as natural and un-self-concious in front of the camera as she is!
And even if you love a good cheesy grin, for goodness sakes keep your cameras out and keep clicking, because you never know what you'll capture.